Six (seemingly) under-priced autographs at Fanatics

If you’re like me, you’re always keeping an eye out for the next piece of memorabilia to go into your fan cave. Autographs of the superstars of yesterday and today are always a fun purchase, but it’s not like we’ve all got a ton of disposable income.

Still, I can’t help myself but to check out my regular rotation of sites to see if there are any good deals. Now, I’ve added Fanatics to that rotation.

I always knew that Fanatics had autographed memorabilia, but I figured it would be on the high end in terms of pricing.

Well… I think I fell down a bit of a rabbit hole. And I found six items that seem almost criminally under-priced.

I’ve highlighted them below, but feel free to check out their entire selection here. 

Here we go.

Grayson Rodriguez Baltimore Orioles Autographed Fanatics Authentic Baseball

The No. 5 prospect in baseball is currently starting for the Orioles. The big righty is just 23-years-old an is striking out opposing hitters at an impressive clip. This seems like it could be a great investment, coming in at just $100.

Joe Burrow Cincinnati Bengals Fanatics Authentic Autographed Riddell Speed Mini Helmet

Joey B is absolutely legit, taking the Bengals to the Super Bowl and the AFC Championship game in back-to-back seasons. It just seems like a matter of time before he wins an MVP Award or finally wins a ring. Again, this price here is steeper, but there’s so much upside.

Jordan Walker St. Louis Cardinals Autographed Fanatics Authentic 16″ x 20″ Opening Day Photograph

Walker entered the 2023 season as the No. 2 prospect in baseball and he’s already making a huge impact in St. Louis. The 20-year-old is batting .269 on the season and had a 12-game hit streak to start the campaign. There are big things in store.

Anthony Richardson Florida Gators Fanatics Authentic Autographed 8″ x 10″ Running Photograph

After an insane performance at the NFL Combine, Anthony Richardson cemented himself as a first round NFL Draft pick next week. Since then, there have been a plethora of rumors surrounding the Florida quarterback – including that the Detroit Lions are prepared to trade up to the No. 3 pick in order to select him. That’s easy money at this point.

Magic Johnson Los Angeles Lakers Fanatics Authentic Autographed NBA Finals Champion Replica Larry O’Brien Trophy with Sublimated Plate

No matter how you slice it, Magic Johnson is one of the 10 best basketball players in the history of the NBA. To get an autograph of his for anything less than $300 is pretty rare. When you consider that this isn’t a photo, but something more unique, this truly seems like a steal.

Joe Montana Notre Dame Fighting Irish Autographed Fanatics Authentic Riddell Speed Mini Helmet

This one might have been the most surprising. Montana is considered one of the best players in league history and many considered him the GOAT until Tom Brady went to Tampa Bay and won another ring. Considering a Burrow autograph is $300, the extra $50 here seems like a great deal.

This post contains affiliate links, where we may receive a percentage of any sale made from the links on this page. Prices and availability are accurate as of the time of publication.