Dog death, driving and emails: The strange history of the 'October surprise' – BBC
Even in a Senate race already marred by insults and mudslinging, the term "puppy killer" stood out.
The term – directed at Trump-backed Pennsylvania Senate hopeful Dr Mehmet Oz – followed a report by the US news website Jezebel that said research led by Dr Oz had killed at least 329 dogs as well as dozens of pigs and hundreds of rabbits and rodents.
While a spokesman for Dr Oz denied the claim and said "only an idiot" would believe it, the celebrity doctor's political opponents were quick to pounce. His election rival, Democrat John Fetterman, branded him "sick" and began selling "Dog Lovers for Fetterman" campaign stickers.
His wife, Gisele Fetterman, also piled on the pressure. "We know what the stakes are in this election… add one more: PUPPIES," she tweeted.
The allegations against Dr Oz came as he was closing the distance in the polls against Mr Fetterman with just one month to go until the 8 November midterm elections.
"When you frame someone as a puppy killer, it's controversial. It's attention-grabbing," Syracuse University Professor Jennifer Stromer Galley, who researches the political impact of social media, told the BBC.
"America loves its dogs," she added. "To be on the wrong side of this particular story is hard as a candidate."
The claims, some experts believe, could be the latest example of what is known as an "October surprise" – news stories that have the potential to upend campaigns and influence voters shortly before the November elections.
Here are some other notable – and varied – October surprises.
The term "October surprise" comes from the 1980 electoral race between then-President Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan, who reportedly feared that a last-minute release of US hostages held in Iran would boost Mr Carter in the polls.
Ultimately, the hostages were released on the same day as Reagan's inaugural address.
Some – including former Iranian President Abdulhassan Banisadr – later claimed that Reagan conspired with Iran to keep the hostages from being released before the election.
Two congressional investigations, however, found no evidence that this was the case.
During the tight final days of the 2000 presidential race between George W Bush and Al Gore, Fox News revealed that Mr Bush had been arrested for drunk driving 24 years earlier in 1976.
While Mr Bush became president, his adviser and strategist Karl Rove later said he believed the news had cost the campaign five states. In a later book, Mr Rove accused Al Gore's press secretary of spreading the news to tip the election.
"The timing of the DUI disclosure – four days before election day, with the candidates tied in the polls – was suspicious," Mr Rove wrote.
The Gore campaign denied any involvement.
Just weeks before Americans headed to the polls to cast their ballots for Mitt Romney or Barack Obama, video emerged of Mr Romney in which he was seen telling a group of campaign donors that "47 percent" of voters would vote for Mr Obama "no matter what".
He added that 47% of voters "believe they are victims" and that "government has a responsibility to care for them".
The videotape immediately put Mr Romney's campaign on the defensive, while Mr Obama's team made mentions of it a fixture of last-minute campaign ads and interviews.
"That hurt," Mr Romney told Fox News. "There's no question that hurt and did real damage to my campaign".
The 2016 presidential election between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump saw a number of last-minute surprises that experts speculated could upset the election.
In early October of that year, a 2005 video emerged showing soon-to-be President Trump saying that "you can do anything" to women "when you're a star". He later apologised.
The very same day, WikiLeaks unveiled emails from John Podesta – who was then chair of the Clinton campaign – which included portions of speeches she gave to Wall Street banks.
Lastly, on 28 October – 11 days before the election – then-FBI Director James Comey announced he would take "appropriate investigative steps" to examine Mrs Clinton's use of an unsecured private email server.
"[It] upended the news cycle, and soon halved Clinton's lead in the polls, imperilling her position in the Electoral college," US writer and FiveThirtyEight founder Nate Silver wrote the following year.
This video can not be played
BBC Reality Check breaks down the bill for the world's most expensive election
Trump-backed celebrity doctor wins Senate primary
Inflation's got her thinking she'd 'vote Trump again'
Trump calls Biden 'enemy of the state' over FBI raid
Fans count down the hours to World Cup final
Russia sends musicians to frontline to boost morale
Top Iran actress who supported protests arrested
Fans count down the hours to World Cup final
How family unity has helped Mbappe to stardom
The forgotten women at the heart of the Bible John mystery
Laura Kuenssberg: 'No coups, no plots – nobody cares'
Making it big selling legal weed is harder than it looks
Lockdown conspiracy theory leads to death threats in UK city
The rare reef that may be threatened by oil drilling
Your pictures on the theme of 'bright lights'
The surprising physics behind Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu
The dark side of a children's classic
Asia's most beautiful train route?
The diseases soaring post-lockdown
© 2022 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.
